Case Insight · Illustrative Scenario
Do I Have to Return Defective Goods to China Before My Supplier Refunds Me?
Published by HAIYU INTERNATIONAL, the international division of Timely Rectitude Law Firm.
- Published
- Last updated
- Dispute Type
- Practical Guide
- Jurisdiction
- China; subject to applicable law, treaty and dispute forum
- Country / Region
- International
- Industry
- Cross-border trade
- Amount Range
- Not applicable; general practical guide
- Authority / Counterparty
- Supplier
Situation
Your supplier says it will refund you once you send the defective goods back to China. Should you book the shipment? There is no single answer based only on the supplier being in China. Whether you must return the goods, and when the refund becomes due, depends on the contract, applicable law, the remedy available and any agreed settlement. A platform dispute process may also set practical requirements and deadlines. Before sending the goods, seek written confirmation of the refund and return arrangements. Otherwise, you may pay for an international shipment while leaving the amount, payment date and responsibility for receiving it unresolved. Start with the contract and applicable law This guide concerns business purchases, not personal consumer returns. Review the purchase contract, specifications, warranty, return provisions, governing-law clause and dispute-resolution clause. A Chinese supplier does not automatically make every issue subject to China's domestic contract rules. In Chinese proceedings, Article 41 of the law governing foreign-related civil relationships recognizes contractual choice of law and provides rules where no choice was made. Official Chinese law: https://cicc.court.gov.cn/html/1/218/62/83/442.html The UN Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods, or CISG, may apply. Check the parties' places of business, relevant treaty status and reservations, and any exclusion. CISG Articles 1, 2 and 6: https://iicl.law.pace.edu/cisg/page/united-nations-convention-contracts-international-sale-goods-1980-cisg ; UNCITRAL status information: https://uncitral.un.org/en/texts/salegoods/conventions/sale_of_goods/cisg/status If China's Civil Code applies, Articles 582 and 617 address remedies for nonconforming goods. Article 610 permits rejection or termination where quality failures defeat the contract's purpose. Article 566 addresses restoration and other remedies after termination. These provisions do not establish a universal refund-before-return rule. Civil Code: https://english.taizhou.gov.cn/Government/LawsandRules/art/2023/art_4afa47a964b94a2c8bef075f8b9ade04.html Under CISG Article 81(2), following valid avoidance of the contract, parties who both owe restitution must perform it concurrently. This is not an automatic right to receive money first. Nor does every defect justify avoidance: Article 49's requirements must be met. Official CISG text: https://treaties.un.org/doc/publication/ctc/ch_x_10.pdf 1. Confirm what the supplier is actually agreeing to Distinguish a return for inspection, a return for repair and an agreed return for a refund. Sending goods for inspection does not necessarily mean the supplier has accepted your refund claim. Ask the supplier to confirm: • The order, products, quantities and batches covered. • Whether it accepts the identified defects or is still investigating them. • Whether the agreed outcome is a refund, replacement, repair or another remedy. • Whether the arrangement settles the entire dispute or only specified items. If inspection remains necessary, agree who will inspect, against which specifications, within what period, and how disagreements will be handled. Avoid an unlimited condition such as “refund after our approval” without an inspection process or deadline. 2. Fix the amount and payment trigger Record the refund amount and currency, permitted deductions, bank charges and whether freight or other expenses are included or reimbursed separately. Then define exactly when payment becomes due. Possible negotiated triggers include collection by the agreed carrier, delivery to an authorized warehouse, or completion of an inspection within a fixed period. These are options to negotiate, not legal entitlements in every case. Specify the deadline after that trigger and the payment method. “After return” is too vague: carrier collection, arrival at a Chinese port, customs release and warehouse receipt are different events. For a significant shipment, consider whether escrow or another agreed arrangement can coordinate the exchange. Check that any proposed mechanism is actually available and what its release conditions require. 3. Verify who will receive the goods Obtain the receiving entity's full legal name, complete address, contact person, telephone number and any return authorization number. If the supplier names a factory, affiliate, agent or third-party warehouse, obtain its written confirmation that this recipient is authorized to receive this particular return. The supplier should also confirm what delivery to that recipient means for the refund obligation. A warehouse signature alone may not resolve a disagreement about authority, contents or condition. Check that the return address matches any applicable platform instructions. Obtain documented approval for changes rather than relying on a private chat alone.
Key Issue
4. Allocate freight, customs costs and failed-delivery risks Agree who arranges transport and who pays or advances: • Packing, pickup, freight and insurance. • Export and import clearance, broker charges, duties and taxes. • Storage, demurrage, inspection and handling charges. • Additional costs if the shipment is delayed, refused or sent back. A dispute about defective goods does not, by itself, resolve every logistics charge. Separate who pays the carrier now from who ultimately bears the cost under the contract, settlement or applicable law. Have the relevant customs broker confirm whether the return is permitted, the correct declaration procedure and required documents in both countries. Do not assume that describing a shipment as a return makes it duty-free. Use accurate descriptions and values; do not misdescribe the goods as gifts or declare an artificial zero value. Also agree who handles clearance, the consequences if the recipient refuses delivery, and how loss or damage during transport affects payment. The buyer and supplier's agreement does not itself bind customs authorities or the carrier. 5. Preserve evidence before handing over the goods Keep the contract, approved samples and specifications, invoices, payment records, original shipping documents, inspection reports and complete correspondence. Before dispatch, record the defects, serial or batch numbers, quantities, packaging and condition. Photograph or video the packing process and link each carton to the packing list. Consider an independent inspection where the amount or technical dispute warrants it. Retain representative samples only where lawful and consistent with the agreed return arrangements, and document them. Continue reasonable care while the dispute is unresolved. CISG Article 86 imposes preservation duties on a buyer intending to reject goods. Article 82 can affect avoidance or replacement rights if restitution in substantially the received condition becomes impossible, subject to exceptions. Official CISG text: https://treaties.un.org/doc/publication/ctc/ch_x_10.pdf Do not casually use, alter, resell or discard disputed stock. For unsafe, perishable or costly-to-store goods, obtain prompt advice about lawful handling and preservation measures rather than assuming indefinite storage is appropriate. 6. Keep legal and platform deadlines separate Notify the supplier promptly and specifically about the defects. Chinese Civil Code Articles 620–622 and CISG Articles 38–39 contain inspection and notice rules whose application depends on the facts. Negotiating a return should not distract you from those requirements. Civil Code: https://english.taizhou.gov.cn/Government/LawsandRules/art/2023/art_4afa47a964b94a2c8bef075f8b9ade04.html ; CISG text: https://iicl.law.pace.edu/cisg/page/united-nations-convention-contracts-international-sale-goods-1980-cisg Separately check the actual platform order, dispute decision and current rules for return deadlines, tracking evidence and refund conditions. A supplier's private assurance should not be assumed to extend a platform deadline. Platform procedures are not a substitute for determining your legal rights. If a deadline is close, urgently seek clarification or an extension through the relevant process and obtain advice. Unresolved return terms do not automatically suspend an existing contractual, legal or platform obligation. A return is not always the best commercial solution Depending on the goods and the dispute, the parties may agree on local repair, a partial refund with the buyer retaining the goods, local collection, or another documented solution. If disposal is proposed, confirm that it is lawful, preserve the necessary evidence and agree responsibility and costs before proceeding. Compare the return cost with the likely recovery. An expensive shipment should form part of a workable resolution, not create a second dispute over logistics. Before you ship You should be able to identify the goods, the refund amount, the payment trigger and deadline, the authorized recipient, the allocation of costs and risks, and the evidence required. Obtain confirmation from the contracting supplier through an authorized representative and keep it with the original transaction records. If any of those points remains unclear, raise it immediately. A short written return-and-refund agreement can make the next step much safer, provided it is consistent with the contract, applicable law and any platform process. This article provides general information for cross-border commercial transactions. It is not legal advice for a particular dispute. No actual client matter is described.
Documents to Review
- Contract
- Approved samples and specifications
- Invoices and payment records
- Original shipping documents
- Inspection reports
- Complete correspondence
Possible China-Side Options
- Depending on the goods and the dispute, the parties may agree on local repair, a partial refund with the buyer retaining the goods, local collection, or another documented solution.
Risk Factors
- Sending goods for inspection does not necessarily mean the supplier has accepted your refund claim.
- Unresolved return terms do not automatically suspend an existing contractual, legal or platform obligation.
Next Step
You should be able to identify the goods, the refund amount, the payment trigger and deadline, the authorized recipient, the allocation of costs and risks, and the evidence required. Obtain confirmation from the contracting supplier through an authorized representative and keep it with the original transaction records.
This is an illustrative dispute scenario for general information and does not describe a specific client matter.
This content describes a typical dispute scenario and is provided for general informational purposes. It does not represent a specific client matter or guarantee any legal outcome.