Case Insight · Illustrative Scenario
Short Shipment from a Chinese Supplier: What Should Buyers Do When Goods Are Missing?
Published by HAIYU INTERNATIONAL, the international division of Timely Rectitude Law Firm.
- Published
- Last updated
- Dispute Type
- Practical Guide
- Jurisdiction
- China; subject to applicable law, treaty and dispute forum
- Country / Region
- International
- Industry
- Cross-border trade
- Amount Range
- Not applicable; general practical guide
- Authority / Counterparty
- Supplier
Situation
Start with the missing quantity and the handover records If fewer goods arrive than you ordered, record the shortage, preserve the shipment evidence and notify the relevant parties promptly. Before deciding who should pay, establish what was due in this delivery and where the goods may have gone missing. A shortage on arrival does not, by itself, prove that the supplier deliberately underloaded the shipment. This guide concerns commercial purchases connected with China. The contract, applicable law, any applicable treaty and the dispute forum must be checked. It is general information, not a report of a client case or a promise of recovery. Check what this shipment was supposed to contain Read the accepted order, specifications, invoice, packing list and later changes together. Was the order to be shipped in one lot or in agreed instalments? Are accessories packed separately? Does the quantity refer to units, sets, cartons, gross weight or net weight? Check any agreed tolerance rather than assuming that every difference is a breach. Prepare one reconciliation line for each product: ordered quantity, quantity due in this shipment, quantity stated as packed, quantity received, missing quantity and the document supporting each figure. Keep disputed figures visible. Do not count a later authorised shipment as missing from the first one. Record the condition before the shipment is broken up Where practicable and safe, arrange counting while the shipment is still identifiable. Photograph the container or vehicle reference, seal number, carton markings, damaged packaging and the delivery condition. Record when and where unloading and counting occurred, who was present and the counting method. If goods must be moved urgently, document the reason and the next storage location. Preserve original photographs and video files, delivery receipts, warehouse records and complete communications. Retain relevant packaging where feasible. If you can note an observed discrepancy on the delivery record, make it specific and accurate; keep a copy. A generic reservation is not a substitute for the notices required by the transport documents or applicable law. A carton count alone may not establish the number of units inside. Likewise, a shipping document may record a declared quantity rather than an independently verified count. Compare available loading photographs, packing records, weight records and destination counts. For valuable or disputed shipments, consider a suitable independent survey before repacking or distributing the goods. Trace the handovers before allocating responsibility Map the route from packing to final delivery, including any warehouse, consolidator, freight forwarder and carrier. Request the records for each handover: package counts, weights, seal changes, exceptions and receipts. Ask the supplier for order-specific loading evidence rather than a general statement that everything was shipped. Distinguish goods never supplied from goods lost after a relevant handover. Review the incorporated Incoterms rule, its version and named place, together with the sale and transport contracts. Incoterms allocate certain obligations, costs and risk between seller and buyer; they do not by themselves determine every remedy or resolve a carrier claim. Paying the freight does not necessarily mean bearing transit risk until arrival. [1] Identify the correct legal entities. The seller, payment recipient, exporter, forwarder and actual carrier may not be the same company. Avoid demanding the same sum from everyone without an identified basis, or accepting an explanation that prematurely releases another potentially responsible party.
Key Issue
Notify the relevant parties while evidence is available Send a clear written notice identifying the order and shipment, the product and quantity missing, the date of discovery and the supporting records available. Follow the contractual notice method and keep evidence of sending and receipt. Request preservation of loading and handover records, a response and a practical inspection arrangement if needed. Do not wait for the supplier and forwarder to settle responsibility before checking your own deadlines. Supplier, carrier, terminal, warehouse and insurer notices can have different requirements. A complaint to the supplier may not preserve a transport or insurance claim. Where the CISG applies, examination and sufficiently specific notice can affect a buyer’s remedies under Articles 38 and 39; exceptions and contractual terms require separate review. There is no single safe notification period for every shipment. Ask counsel promptly if discovery was delayed or a deadline may already have passed. [2] Choose a remedy that fits the shortage A commercial proposal may involve delivery of the missing goods, an agreed partial refund or a credit that the buyer is willing and able to use. Record the calculation, currency and affected products. A credit against a future order is not cash repayment, and may be unattractive if you do not intend to trade with the supplier again. If the CISG governs, Article 51 distinguishes remedies concerning the missing part from avoidance of the entire contract. Whole-contract avoidance requires the partial failure to amount to a fundamental breach of the contract. Missing some goods does not automatically justify cancelling everything. Any formal remedy, notice or additional performance period should be reviewed against the facts and applicable rules. [3] Keep separate records of additional freight, survey costs, replacement purchases and other claimed loss. Explain how each expense relates to the shortage and what steps were taken to limit avoidable loss. A receipt proves expenditure, not necessarily that the other party must reimburse it. Avoid unilateral deductions from unrelated payments without advice on the contractual and legal position. Put a replenishment agreement in writing Before accepting “we will add it to your next order,” clarify the following: The precise missing products, specifications and quantities to be supplied. A firm dispatch or delivery milestone, and what evidence will demonstrate performance. Who arranges and pays for transport, insurance, clearance, duties and other agreed charges. Whether a new purchase or further payment is required, and whether you actually accept that condition. The remedy if replenishment fails, and whether any release takes effect only after agreed performance. Check that the person making the commitment has authority for the relevant company. Do not sign a broad settlement or release simply to receive goods already promised without understanding which other claims it would affect. Prepare a focused file for legal review Provide the accepted order and amendments; quantity reconciliation; invoices and payment records; packing and transport documents; loading, receipt and survey evidence; complete notices and replies; and a short timeline. Identify the companies involved, the amount in dispute and every known deadline. Mark assumptions and missing records rather than presenting them as established facts. The immediate goal is a checkable explanation of what is missing and when the discrepancy arose. That gives a reviewer a basis to assess the responsible party, realistic remedies, forum and recovery costs. Sources and related guidance [1] ICC, Incoterms and Commercial Contracts. Explanation of obligations, risk, costs and the limits of Incoterms: https://library.iccwbo.org/clp/clp-incoterms-qa-2020.htm?AGENT=ICC_HQ [2] UNCITRAL, Digest of Case Law on the CISG, 2016, Articles 38–40: https://uncitral.un.org/sites/default/files/media-documents/uncitral/en/cisg_digest_2016.pdf [3] United Nations, UNCITRAL Digest, Article 51, including the Convention text: https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/535388/files/A_CN.9_SER.C_DIGEST_CISG_51-EN.pdf Related Haiyu guide on quality evidence: https://www.haiyulaw.com/insights/chinese-supplier-quality-dispute-evidence-beyond-inspection-report Related Haiyu guide on supplier breach: https://www.haiyulaw.com/insights/chinese-supplier-breach-of-contract
Documents to Review
- Accepted order and amendments
- Quantity reconciliation
- Invoices and payment records
- Packing and transport documents
- Loading, receipt and survey evidence
- Complete notices and replies
- A short timeline
Possible China-Side Options
- A commercial proposal may involve delivery of the missing goods, an agreed partial refund or a credit that the buyer is willing and able to use.
Risk Factors
- Missing some goods does not automatically justify cancelling everything.
- A complaint to the supplier may not preserve a transport or insurance claim.
Next Step
The immediate goal is a checkable explanation of what is missing and when the discrepancy arose. That gives a reviewer a basis to assess the responsible party, realistic remedies, forum and recovery costs.
This is an illustrative dispute scenario for general information and does not describe a specific client matter.
This content describes a typical dispute scenario and is provided for general informational purposes. It does not represent a specific client matter or guarantee any legal outcome.