Case Insight · Illustrative Scenario

Chinese Supplier Demands the Balance Before Inspection: What Should Buyers Check?

Published by HAIYU INTERNATIONAL, the international division of Timely Rectitude Law Firm.

Published
Last updated
Dispute Type
Practical Guide
Jurisdiction
Country / Region
Industry
Amount Range
Authority / Counterparty

Situation

Your Chinese supplier says production is complete. Before allowing an inspector into the factory, however, it asks you to pay the remaining balance. Paying may leave you with less practical leverage if the goods fail inspection. Refusing may create a payment dispute if the balance is already due. The starting point is the agreed sequence of payment, inspection and delivery. A general concern about quality does not, by itself, establish a right to withhold payment. 1. Identify what actually triggers the balance payment Gather the signed contract, purchase order, pro forma invoice, accepted quotations and messages recording any changes. Read the payment provisions alongside the inspection and delivery terms. These arrangements raise different questions: • Balance after a satisfactory inspection: Has the agreed inspection occurred, and what counts as a satisfactory result? • Balance on completion of production: What evidence establishes completion? Is inspection separately required before payment? • Balance before shipment: Does another clause place inspection before payment, or only before dispatch? • Payment on a fixed date: Was that date subsequently changed by agreement? Do not treat “before shipment” as a complete answer to every inspection question. Likewise, a general promise of good quality does not necessarily make an inspection report a payment condition. Ask the supplier to identify the contractual provision supporting its demand. Separate an existing payment obligation from a proposed change to the deal. 2. Check the inspection arrangement in practical detail An inspection clause is more useful when it answers operational questions: • Who may inspect: the buyer, a named agency or another independent inspector? • Where and when can the inspection take place? • Must all goods be finished and available, or is sampling permitted? • Which specifications, approved samples and test methods apply? • Who pays for the initial inspection and any reinspection? • What happens after a failed inspection? • How does the result affect payment and shipment? If these points are missing, propose a written inspection plan. Do not describe a newly requested procedure as an existing contractual right unless the documents support that position. Production photos can help identify the goods and their apparent condition. They should not be treated as a substitute for testing that the order requires. 3. Determine which legal rules apply An overseas purchase from a Chinese supplier does not automatically mean every issue is governed solely by China’s domestic sales rules. The United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods, or CISG, may apply to an international goods sale. Its applicability depends on matters including the parties’ places of business, relevant treaty rules and reservations, and any effective exclusion. Review the governing-law clause rather than assuming it settles the question by itself. Source: UNCITRAL’s CISG overview https://uncitral.un.org/en/texts/salegoods/conventions/sale_of_goods/cisg Where the CISG applies, Article 58(3) generally provides an opportunity to examine goods before payment, but expressly recognises an exception where the parties’ agreed delivery or payment procedures are inconsistent with that opportunity. It is therefore unsafe to read the provision as an unconditional right to demand a factory inspection before paying under every contract. Source: UNCITRAL Digest on Article 58 https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/535395/files/A_CN.9_SER.C_DIGEST_CISG_58-EN.pdf Where China’s Civil Code governs the issue, Article 628 starts with the agreed payment time. Articles 525–526 address performance defences according to the order of obligations. Articles 527–528 impose specific conditions on suspension by a party required to perform first, including evidence and notification requirements. Suspecting a quality problem is not automatically enough. Source: Civil Code, published by the Supreme People’s Court https://www.court.gov.cn/zixun/xiangqing/233181.html

Key Issue

4. Send a specific proposal before positions harden Avoid beginning with an accusation of fraud or an unconditional refusal to pay. First, request a workable arrangement tied to the order. A practical proposal can specify: 1. The order number, goods and outstanding balance. 2. The proposed inspector, date, factory address and contact. 3. The specifications and tests to be checked. 4. How the report will be shared. 5. The proposed payment and dispatch sequence. 6. How defects and reinspection will be handled. If the existing agreement requires payment first, ask for a written variation rather than claiming the sequence has already changed. Possible negotiated arrangements include a short extension, staged payment or an agreed retention. These require agreement and may not suit every transaction. Before paying an unfamiliar beneficiary, independently verify the account details through an established contact channel. 5. Preserve the evidence of access and readiness Keep a dated record of the supplier’s statement that production is complete and its response to the inspection request. Useful material includes: • The complete contract and subsequent amendments. • Payment records and the latest balance calculation. • Specifications, approved samples and drawings. • Production records, photographs and relevant communications. • The inspection booking and scope. • Written reasons for denying or restricting access. • Payment reminders, shipment deadlines and cancellation threats. Preserve original emails, files and chat exports where possible, rather than relying only on cropped screenshots. Ask the inspector to record what was available, what was inaccessible and which tests could not be performed. 6. Obtain advice before withholding payment or cancelling Prompt review is particularly useful when the payment deadline is close, the supplier refuses access required by the contract, or the documents contain conflicting terms. A lawyer should assess the applicable law, contractual sequence, evidence and dispute-resolution clause before advising whether payment can be suspended or the contract terminated. A demand for payment first does not itself establish fraud or a right to cancel. An inspection also has a defined scope. Passing a sample inspection does not establish that every unit has been checked. Agree how later defects and warranty claims will be handled, and seek advice on any applicable notification deadlines. The practical takeaway Before deciding whether to pay, answer three questions: When is payment due? What inspection opportunity was agreed? What legal basis supports any proposed delay? Then put a concrete inspection and payment proposal in writing. Clear documents and a timely response are more useful than an argument over whether buyers should “always inspect first.” For an initial review, prepare the contract, pro forma invoice, payment records, inspection provisions and the supplier’s latest demand. These documents help identify the immediate decision and the risks attached to it. This article provides general information for commercial buyers. It is not advice on a particular transaction.

Documents to Review

  • The complete contract and subsequent amendments.
  • Payment records and the latest balance calculation.
  • Specifications, approved samples and drawings.
  • Production records, photographs and relevant communications.
  • The inspection booking and scope.
  • Written reasons for denying or restricting access.
  • Payment reminders, shipment deadlines and cancellation threats.

Possible China-Side Options

  • If the existing agreement requires payment first, ask for a written variation rather than claiming the sequence has already changed.
  • Possible negotiated arrangements include a short extension, staged payment or an agreed retention. These require agreement and may not suit every transaction.

Risk Factors

  • A demand for payment first does not itself establish fraud or a right to cancel.
  • Passing a sample inspection does not establish that every unit has been checked.

Next Step

For an initial review, prepare the contract, pro forma invoice, payment records, inspection provisions and the supplier’s latest demand. These documents help identify the immediate decision and the risks attached to it.

This is an illustrative dispute scenario for general information and does not describe a specific client matter.

This content describes a typical dispute scenario and is provided for general informational purposes. It does not represent a specific client matter or guarantee any legal outcome.

Explore China Dispute HelpContract and commercial dispute servicesLitigation and urgent legal support